Guide

AI recommends my competitor instead of me: what to do

Updated · 10 min read · By the SearchCrow team

When ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google's AI features recommend a competitor and not you, it is almost never a judgement that they are better. The assistant searched the web, found more (or clearer) material about them for that question, and summarised what it found. So the fix is to work out exactly what it could read about them that it can't read about you, and close those gaps one at a time: listings, reviews, plainly stated facts on your website, and content that answers the specific question.

Key takeaways

  • AI assistants recommend what they can find and verify. A competitor being named means their evidence is easier to find for that question, not that the assistant has ranked quality.
  • The assistant's own citations tell you where it looked. Read every one and build a gap table: where they are listed, reviewed and written about that you aren't.
  • Close the quickest gaps first: facts on your site, missing listings and unanswered questions. Reviews and third-party mentions take longer but matter most.
  • You can publish an honest comparison page in the UK, but comparisons with a named competitor have to follow the CAP Code: accurate, objective, verifiable and never denigrating.
  • Never buy, write or cherry-pick reviews, and never run down a rival. Both are illegal or regulated in the UK and are the fastest way to lose the trust you are trying to build.

Why does AI recommend my competitor and not me?

Because when the assistant searched, your competitor had more material that matched the question.

The main assistants answer business questions by searching live and summarising what comes back. OpenAI says ChatGPT search "typically rewrites your query into one or more targeted queries" that it sends to search providers, "ranks search results using multiple factors intended to help users find relevant, reliable information", and that "Placement is not guaranteed" (OpenAI Help Center, 2026). Perplexity says it "searches the internet, gathering information from authoritative sources like articles, websites, and journals" and that "Every answer includes citations linking to the original sources" (Perplexity Help Center, 2026). Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode rely on "our core Search ranking systems to retrieve relevant, up-to-date web pages" and can "show what's being said about products and services across the web" (Google Search Central, 2026).

Put those together and the pattern is clear. A customer asks "who's the best emergency plumber in Reading?" (an illustrative example). The assistant runs several searches, reads directories, review sites, local articles and business websites, and names the businesses that appear most consistently with the clearest supporting detail. If your competitor is on three directories you aren't on, has far more recent reviews, and has a page that says "emergency plumber, Reading, 24 hours, from £95 call-out", they get named. You don't, even if you'd do the job better.

Our guide to how AI assistants choose businesses covers what each platform documents. The practical point here is that the competitor's advantage is readable, and therefore copyable.

How do I find out exactly why the AI prefers them?

Ask the assistants the questions where your competitor wins, then read every citation and record what they have that you don't.

Set aside an hour. Answers vary between runs, so run each question at least twice.

  1. Write down 8 to 12 questions your customers actually ask. Mix intents: urgent ("boiler not working, who can come today in Guildford?"), comparison ("X or Y for a wedding cake in Bath?"), price ("how much does a will cost in Leeds?") and trust ("is [competitor] any good?"). These are illustrative examples; use your own words and towns.
  2. Ask ChatGPT (with search on), Perplexity and Google AI Mode each question. Note who is named, in what order, and what is said about each business.
  3. Open every citation. OpenAI advises exactly this for checking answers: "Open a cited source to check that it supports the answer" (OpenAI Help Center, 2026). For your purposes, each citation is a place the assistant looked.
  4. Build a gap table. One row per source the assistant cited or clearly drew on: the source, whether your competitor is on it, whether you are, and what their entry says that yours doesn't.

A gap table for a fictional accountancy firm might look like this:

Source cited by the assistantCompetitorYouGap
Google Business Profile64 reviews, replies to all, services listed with prices9 reviews, no replies, no services listedVolume, recency, replies, services
ICAEW "Find a chartered accountant" directoryListed with specialismsNot listedAdd the listing
Local news site, "accountants for start-ups" featureQuotedNot mentionedPitch a quote or article
Competitor's own "Pricing" pageFixed fees stated on page"Contact us for a quote"Publish prices or ranges

Then look beyond the citations:

  • Their website. Read it as a stranger. What does it state in plain text that yours doesn't: services, prices, areas covered, hours, qualifications, years trading, named staff? Google's local ranking help says "Businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results" (Google Business Profile Help, 2026).
  • Their reviews. Count them, check how recent the latest ten are, and see whether the owner replies. Google lists "how many reviews you have" among the things prominence is based on, and says "More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking" (Google Business Profile Help, 2026).
  • Their content. Have they published a "best X in [town]" roundup, a comparison page, or answers to the exact questions you asked? An assistant searching for "best X in town" will read a page with that title.

How do I close the gaps?

Work through the table from quickest to slowest, and aim to be at least as readable as the competitor on every source the assistant cited.

1. Get on the same sources

If the assistant cited a directory, trade register, review site or local publication that lists your competitor and not you, that is your first job. Match the specific sources the assistant used rather than paying for bulk directory submissions: Google warns that "seeking inauthentic 'mentions' across the web isn't as helpful as it might seem" (Google Search Central, 2026). Our AI visibility checklist walks through the core listings.

2. State plainly on your website what they state plainly

For every gap that comes from their website, add the equivalent to yours in plain text: a services page with prices or ranges, the towns you cover, hours, qualifications with registration numbers, and who runs the business. Google lists keeping "Business Profile information" up to date among its best practices for AI features (Google Search Central, 2025); the same facts belong on your site.

3. Answer the specific questions where they win

Take each question that named the competitor and write a page that answers it in the first two sentences, then adds detail. "How much does a will cost in Leeds?" deserves a page with real figures and what changes them. Google's query fan-out means the assistant is "issuing multiple related searches across subtopics" (Google Search Central, 2025), so a page that answers one sub-question well can be cited even if your home page isn't.

4. Build reviews the right way

Ask every customer, the same way, after every job, with a direct link. Reply to every review, including the bad ones; Google says replying "shows that you value their feedback" (Google Business Profile Help, 2026). Our Google Business Profile and reviews guide has scripts.

5. Publish your own honest comparison page

If customers ask assistants to compare you with competitors, a comparison page written by you puts your side on the record and gives assistants a page to read when someone asks "X or Y?". Two forms work:

  • A comparison against typical options: "how to choose a [service] in [town]", with a table of what varies (price, response time, qualifications, guarantees) and your own figures stated honestly. This names nobody.
  • A head-to-head with a named competitor. Legal in the UK, but regulated. Read the next section first.

What can I say about a competitor in a comparison page?

Only things that are accurate, objective, verifiable and fair, and nothing that runs them down.

The UK's CAP Code (the non-broadcast advertising code enforced by the Advertising Standards Authority) applies to marketing on your own website. Its rules on comparisons with an identifiable competitor (ASA/CAP, 2026) say such comparisons:

  • "must not mislead, or be likely to mislead, the consumer about either the advertised product or the competing product" (rule 3.32);
  • "must compare products meeting the same needs or intended for the same purpose" (3.33);
  • "must objectively compare one or more material, relevant, verifiable and representative feature of those products, which may include price" (3.34);
  • "must not create confusion between the marketer and its competitors" (3.35);
  • "must not discredit or denigrate another product, marketer, trade mark, trade name or other distinguishing mark" (3.41).

The ASA also notes that a competitor counts as identifiable "if a consumer can identify at least one competitor or competing product", that "Marketers should hold documentary evidence to back up all comparative claims", and that you should not omit "any information that consumers are likely to need to form an opinion on the relative merits" of what is compared (ASA, 2026). On verifiability, the ASA says ads "should clearly explain how readers can verify a comparison", setting out the information or signposting where it can be checked; simply including a web address is unlikely to be enough (ASA, 2026).

In practice, for a head-to-head page:

  1. Compare like with like: the same service, at the same level, for the same kind of customer.
  2. Use facts you can document with a date: published prices, stated response times, listed qualifications. Screenshot the competitor's page the day you take the figure.
  3. Say how a reader can verify each figure ("prices taken from each firm's website on 10 November 2026").
  4. Leave out opinions about their quality, staff or character. "We offer a 12-month guarantee; they state 6 months" is a comparison. "They cut corners" is not.
  5. Include the things they do better; the ASA expects you not to omit information readers need.
  6. Review the page every few months; a comparison that was true in January can mislead by June.

One line of caution on defamation: a false statement that harms a competitor's reputation can be actionable, and for a business the Defamation Act 2013 treats harm as serious where it "has caused or is likely to cause the body serious financial loss" (legislation.gov.uk, 2026). Stick to documented facts and you are also protecting yourself.

What should I not do?

Don't fake, buy or cherry-pick reviews, and don't attack competitors, online or in reviews.

Fake and incentivised reviews are illegal in the UK. The Competition and Markets Authority's fake reviews guidance (CMA208, published 4 April 2025) explains the banned practice in the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which "covers fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and requires traders not to publish consumer reviews (and information derived from them) in a misleading way" (Competition and Markets Authority, 2025). The law "bans both submitting and commissioning another person to submit or write a banned review", and commissioning "includes incentivising by any means".

Cherry-picking counts too. The same guidance says cherry-picking positive reviews "might be done either through suppressing negative reviews that have been submitted or by encouraging just those who are satisfied to leave reviews" (Competition and Markets Authority, 2025). So the tempting shortcut of only sending the review link to happy customers is a problem. Send it to everyone.

Don't review competitors or get friends to. Google's Maps content policy prohibits content posted "on a competitor's place or business to undermine that business' or product's reputation" and content based on a conflict of interest, which it says may include "industry competitors" (Google Maps Help, 2026). It also bans reviews "that have been paid for, directly or in kind".

Don't disparage rivals in your content. Beyond the CAP Code's denigration rule, assistants summarise what they read; a page full of digs at a competitor gives them nothing citable about you.

Don't chase every competitor at once. Pick the one or two named most often for the questions that matter to your revenue, and close their gaps first.

How do I know when it's working?

Re-run the same questions on a fixed schedule and track who is named, not just whether you are.

Keep the question list unchanged, run it every two to four weeks, and record whether you were named, who else was, and which sources were cited. Progress usually shows first in the citations (your new listing or page starts appearing), then in mentions alongside the competitor, then in being named first. Because answers vary between runs, look for the trend over several checks rather than any one result. Our guides to AI competitor analysis and checking if ChatGPT recommends your business go deeper on the method.

How SearchCrow helps

The free check at searchcrow.com/check asks ChatGPT and Perplexity five questions a customer might ask about your business and shows which assistants named you, who was recommended instead, and the top three fixes. On paid plans, competitor pages give you a head-to-head report against named competitors, the sites they are mentioned on that you aren't (the gap table above, kept up to date), and an email alert when a competitor overtakes you. Everything in this guide can be done by hand; SearchCrow just removes the hour of repeat checking each month. Plans are on the pricing page.

FAQ

Why does ChatGPT recommend my competitor and not me? Because it found more, or clearer, material about them when it searched. OpenAI says ChatGPT search rewrites your question into targeted queries, sends them to search providers and ranks results on multiple factors, and that placement is not guaranteed. If a competitor has more listings, reviews and plainly stated services for those queries, they get named. It is not a verdict on who is better.

Can I publish a page comparing my business to a named competitor in the UK? Yes, if you follow the CAP Code. Comparisons with an identifiable competitor must not mislead, must compare products meeting the same needs, must objectively compare material, relevant, verifiable and representative features, and must not discredit or denigrate the competitor. Hold evidence for every claim and tell readers how they can check it. Many businesses find a comparison against typical options in their area safer and just as useful.

Should I ask only my happiest customers for reviews to catch up? No. The CMA's fake reviews guidance says cherry-picking positive reviews can include encouraging just those who are satisfied to leave reviews, and treats it as a way of publishing reviews in a misleading way under the DMCC Act 2024. Ask every customer, the same way, after every job. Genuine volume and recency are what you are trying to build, and they stand up to scrutiny.

How long will it take to overtake a competitor in AI answers? There is no published timeline, and answers vary between runs, so judge progress over weeks of repeated checks rather than one screenshot. Listing and website fixes can be read by assistants on their next search; reviews and third-party mentions build over months. Fix the gaps that are quickest first (facts on your site, missing listings) while the slower work (reviews, mentions) accumulates.

Is it worth tracking which competitors AI names? Yes, because the competitor's citations tell you exactly which sources the assistant trusts for your type of question. Re-run the same questions on a fixed schedule, record who is named and which sites are cited, and compare your list with theirs. That gap list is your action plan. SearchCrow's free check shows who was recommended instead of you, and paid plans track named competitors over time.

Sources

Free check

Does ChatGPT recommend your business?

Free, in under a minute. You’ll see whether AI assistants mention you, who they recommend instead, and your top 3 fixes.

We’ll read your website for your business details, so there’s less to type.

Free, no card needed. We ask ChatGPT and Perplexity 5 questions your customers might ask, and check your website. We use your email to send you your results and a few short follow-ups about them, which you can stop with one click; see our privacy notice.