Industry guide

How insurance brokers get recommended by AI assistants

Updated · 9 min read · By the SearchCrow team

AI assistants recommend insurance brokers when they can find a specific answer to the customer's real problem: who will insure this unusual home, car, business or trip, and can I trust them? That means naming the risks you place in plain text, keeping your FCA register entry accurate, and being listed where people look for regulated brokers, such as BIBA's Find insurance service. Comparison sites win on standard cover; brokers win on the cases those sites can't handle.

Key takeaways

  • People ask AI about awkward risks: a flood-risk postcode, a listed building, a young driver with a conviction, travel cover with a medical condition. Specialist pages answer those prompts.
  • MoneyHelper tells consumers that comparison sites offer fairly generic policies and sends them to BIBA's Find insurance service to find a regulated broker.
  • The FCA register is the public check. ICOBS 4.1.2R already requires you to tell customers you're on it and how to verify that.
  • Your website and social posts can be financial promotions. They must be clear, fair and not misleading (ICOBS 2.2.2R), and "cheapest price" claims carry extra FCA guidance.

This page is general marketing guidance, not regulatory or legal advice. Check anything you publish with your compliance function or, if you're an appointed representative, your principal.

What do customers ask AI when they're looking for an insurance broker?

They describe the risk that other insurers turned down, or the cover they can't find online. The prompts below are illustrative examples of the kinds of questions people ask, not measured search volumes.

IntentExample prompts (illustrative)
Urgent"My home insurer won't renew because of subsidence, who can cover me before the end of the month?", "I need public liability for a market stall this weekend"
Comparison"Insurance broker or comparison site for a thatched cottage?", "Is a broker more expensive than going direct?"
Local"Commercial insurance broker in Norwich for a restaurant", "Broker near Truro who does holiday let insurance"
Price"How much is professional indemnity for a sole trader consultant?", "Do insurance brokers charge a fee on top of the premium?"
Trust"Is [broker name] FCA authorised?", "Reviews of [broker name] for classic car insurance"

Where does AI get its answers about insurance brokers?

From public pages it can check: your website, the FCA register, consumer guidance, trade body directories, comparison sites and review platforms. Google says its AI Overviews and AI Mode use pages that are indexed and eligible to show with a snippet, with no additional technical requirements (Google Search Central, n.d.).

SourceWhat it isWhy it matters for brokers
Your websiteLines of business, specialist schemes, team, regulatory statusThe only place that can explain in full which risks you place and how.
FCA Financial Services RegisterRecord of authorised firms and individuals, with appointed representatives (ARs) listed against their principalsThe definitive check of whether you can arrange insurance (FCA, n.d.).
MoneyHelperGovernment-backed money guidanceIts broker guide says comparison sites are "a good place to scan the market quickly" but not always the best way to buy, and points people to BIBA (MoneyHelper, n.d.).
BIBA Find insurance serviceThe British Insurance Brokers' Association's consumer serviceA phone line (0370 950 1790, Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm) and category search, plus specialist directories for cyber, flood, armed forces and travel medical cover (BIBA, n.d.).
MoneyHelper travel insurance directoryShortlist of specialists for travellers with health conditionsSays all listed firms are FCA authorised and "selected based on proof of their specialism" (MoneyHelper, n.d.).
Chartered Insurance InstituteProfessional bodyAwards a corporate Chartered title to insurance brokers and runs a "find a Chartered firm" search (CII, n.d.).
Comparison sitesPrice tables for standard motor, home, travel and van coverStrong on "cheapest" questions. Your edge is the risks they can't quote.
Trustpilot and FeefoReview platformsTrustpilot lets anyone with a genuine experience review you; Feefo says all its reviews come from verified customers (Trustpilot, 2026; Feefo, n.d.).
US equivalentState insurance departmentsThe NAIC lets consumers select a state to search for an insurance agent or file a complaint (NAIC, n.d.).

Why do comparison sites beat brokers on some questions and not others?

Because they answer different questions. MoneyHelper says policies offered on comparison websites "will be fairly generic", and that "you also won't find specialist or bespoke cover on there", giving a high-value antique and travel insurance with a pre-existing condition as examples (MoneyHelper, n.d.). It adds that brokers are paid commission by the insurer and can help with claims.

So don't fight the aggregators on "cheapest car insurance for a 40-year-old". Write about the cases where someone has to talk to a person. Typical examples, spelled out the way customers describe them:

  • Non-standard homes: thatched roofs, timber frames, listed buildings, properties with past subsidence, homes in flood-risk postcodes, unoccupied or probate properties.
  • Drivers and vehicles: young or newly qualified drivers, drivers with convictions or points, classic and modified cars, imported vehicles, campervans, taxis and private hire, motor trade.
  • Small businesses: tradespeople's public liability and tools cover, landlords and holiday lets, restaurants and takeaways, professional indemnity for consultants, cyber cover, event cover, fleet and goods in transit.
  • Personal lines with a twist: high-value homes and collections, travel cover with medical conditions, cover for people with unspent convictions.

Only list the ones you genuinely place. An assistant may repeat your page to someone you then have to turn away.

What do the FCA rules mean for your marketing?

They set the floor for anything an assistant might repeat about you.

  • Your website is a promotion. The FCA says financial promotions "can take the form of a website, Facebook post, tweet, etc." and must be clear, fair and not misleading whatever the medium. It lists home, motor and travel insurance among the products whose advertising it regulates (FCA, n.d.).
  • Clear, fair and not misleading. ICOBS 2.2.2R applies this to all information you give customers, including promotions, and ICOBS 2.2.2A requires marketing communications to be "clearly identifiable as such" (FCA Handbook, 2026).
  • Pricing claims. Guidance at ICOBS 2.2.4G covers promotions that say or imply you can reduce premiums or provide the cheapest premium. They should be consistent with the result most responding customers can reasonably expect (unless the proportion who will achieve it is stated prominently) and should state prominently the basis for the claim and any significant limitations.
  • Say what you are. Before a first contract, ICOBS 4.1.2R requires you to give your identity and address, say whether you give a personal recommendation, explain how to complain to you and the Financial Ombudsman Service, and tell the customer you're on the Financial Services Register and how to verify that. ICOBS 4.1.6R requires you to say whether you advise on the basis of a fair and personal analysis or, if not, which insurers you deal with (FCA Handbook, 2026). Your website should match what you tell customers.
  • Panels. ICOBS 4.1.8G says a panel can support a fair analysis only if it is big enough, reviewed regularly and chosen on product features, premiums and service, "not solely on the benefit offered to the firm". Don't describe a short panel as "the whole market".
  • The Consumer Duty. Firms must "act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers", and one of the four outcomes is consumer understanding: plain-language information at the right moment (FCA, n.d.).
  • Appointed representatives. An AR "carries on regulated activity under the responsibility of an authorised firm", and the principal is responsible for its compliance (FCA, n.d.). Check your principal's sign-off process for web and directory copy.
  1. Make your register entry and website agree. Check your firm or AR entry on the FCA register. Firms update details through Connect, and most must check and confirm them each year, including registered and trading names (FCA, n.d.). Put your firm reference number, and your principal's name if you're an AR, in your site footer.

  2. Write one page per specialism. For each risk you place, say who it's for, what the insurer usually needs to know (survey, claims history, security, convictions), how long a quote typically takes with you, and what you can't cover. Use the customer's words: "thatched cottage insurance", not "non-standard property solutions".

  3. Describe your service accurately. Say whether you give advice or information only, and whether you search a panel or work with named insurers, in the same terms as your status disclosure. "We place cover with a panel of specialist insurers and Lloyd's markets" is a fact an assistant can repeat; "access to the whole market" may not be true.

  4. Explain how you're paid. MoneyHelper tells consumers brokers are paid commission. If you also charge a broker fee, say so and give it in pounds. People ask assistants this directly.

  5. Get listed where people look for brokers. If you're a BIBA member, keep your Find insurance details current, and check whether one of its specialist directories (such as flood or travel medical) fits what you do (BIBA, n.d.). If you place travel cover for people with medical conditions, look at MoneyHelper's travel insurance directory criteria. If your firm holds Chartered status from the CII, say so on your site.

  6. Complete your Google Business Profile properly. Use your real trading name without keywords, pick the fewest and most specific categories, and if customers don't visit your office, hide your address as a service-area business. A virtual office isn't eligible (Google Business Profile Help, n.d.).

  7. Ask every client for a review, the same way, with no incentive. Google prohibits incentivised reviews and selectively asking only happy customers (Google Business Profile Help, n.d.; Google, n.d.). Trustpilot asks businesses to invite "consistently and fairly" and not to pick and choose (Trustpilot, 2026). The CMA published guidance in April 2025 on the new consumer law covering fake and concealed incentivised reviews (CMA, 2025). A good moment is after a claim is settled. A negative review that alleges financial loss, material distress or material inconvenience can meet the FCA's definition of a complaint (FCA Handbook, n.d.), so pass it to whoever handles complaints, and never discuss a client's claim in a public reply.

  8. Add InsuranceAgency structured data. Schema.org's InsuranceAgency sits under FinancialService and LocalBusiness (Schema.org, n.d.). Google recommends the most specific subtype, with name, address, phone and opening hours that match the visible page (Google Search Central, n.d.).

Also ask whoever runs your website to check that robots.txt and any firewall allow OAI-SearchBot, which OpenAI uses to surface sites in ChatGPT search (OpenAI, n.d.), PerplexityBot (Perplexity, n.d.) and Claude-SearchBot (Anthropic, n.d.). See how to allow ChatGPT to crawl your website.

Mistakes that keep brokers out of AI answers

  • "All your insurance needs." It matches nothing anyone asks. Name the risks.
  • Specialisms hidden in a PDF or a quote form. If the only mention of "thatched" is inside a form dropdown, there's nothing for an assistant to read.
  • "Cheapest" or "we'll beat any quote" without evidence. ICOBS 2.2.4G guidance applies, and an assistant may repeat the claim to someone it doesn't apply to.
  • "Whole of market" when you use a panel. It contradicts your status disclosure.
  • A trading name that differs between Google, BIBA and the FCA register. Inconsistent facts make it harder to be sure it's the same firm. See ChatGPT has wrong information about my business.

How do you check whether AI recommends your brokerage?

Ask the assistants what your customers ask, and record the answers monthly.

  1. Choose 10 prompts from the table, using your town and your three main specialisms.
  2. Run each in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google (AI Overviews and AI Mode), Gemini, Claude and Copilot, logged out or in a private window where possible. Answers vary between users and days.
  3. Note whether you're named, which brokers, comparison sites or insurers appear instead, and which sources are cited.
  4. Check facts about you, especially regulatory status, fees and the risks you cover, and fix the source page if anything is wrong.
  5. In Google Search Console, traffic from AI features is counted in the Performance report under the "Web" search type (Google Search Central, n.d.).

SearchCrow automates this. The free check asks ChatGPT and Perplexity five questions a customer might ask and shows whether you're named, who was named instead and the top three fixes. Mortgage and financial advice firms have their own pages at /for/mortgage-brokers and /for/financial-advisers.

FAQ

Why doesn't ChatGPT recommend my insurance brokerage? Usually because your website doesn't say, in plain text, which awkward risks you place. People ask AI about thatched cottages, flood-risk postcodes, convicted drivers or travel cover with a heart condition. If your site says "competitive quotes for all your insurance needs", an assistant has nothing to match. A broker with one clear page per specialism, an accurate FCA register entry and consistent directory listings is far easier to recommend.

Can a broker compete with comparison sites in AI answers? Comparison sites are built for quick quotes on standard cover, so compete where they are weakest. MoneyHelper says policies on comparison websites are fairly generic and that specialist or bespoke cover won't be found there, giving a high-value antique and travel insurance with a pre-existing condition as examples. Write about the risks and circumstances you actually place, and leave cheapest-price questions to the aggregators.

Can I say "we'll beat your renewal price" on my website? Be careful. FCA guidance at ICOBS 2.2.4G says a promotion that claims to reduce premiums or offer the cheapest price should match the result most customers who respond can reasonably expect, unless you state prominently what proportion will achieve it. It should also state the basis for the claim and any significant limitations. Run any pricing claim past your compliance function first.

Is BIBA's Find Insurance service worth being part of? MoneyHelper sends consumers looking for a regulated broker to BIBA's Find insurance service and gives its phone number, so it is one of the public routes into broking that assistants can read. BIBA also runs specialist directories, including cyber, flood and travel medical cover. Whether to join depends on your business, but no AI platform has said it weights BIBA membership in its answers.

What structured data should an insurance broker use? Schema.org has an InsuranceAgency type, which sits under FinancialService and LocalBusiness. Use it with your trading name, address, phone, website and opening hours, keeping each value identical to your visible page and your FCA register entry. Google says its AI features need no special markup, so structured data keeps your facts consistent rather than boosting you.

Sources

Free check

Find out what AI says when people ask for insurance brokers

Free, in under a minute. You’ll see whether AI assistants mention you, who they recommend instead, and your top 3 fixes.

We’ll read your website for your business details, so there’s less to type.

Free, no card needed. We ask ChatGPT and Perplexity 5 questions your customers might ask, and check your website. We use your email to send you your results and a few short follow-ups about them, which you can stop with one click; see our privacy notice.