A comparison page that AI assistants quote answers a "who should I choose?" question with a table of real, named local options, including you, where every cell is a fact a reader could check: services, areas, hours, accreditations, starting prices and review scores, each with a date. It works because assistants answer those questions by searching the web and reading what comes back, and a page that already lays the options side by side matches the question better than any home page. In the UK you can name competitors on your own site, provided the comparison is accurate, objective and not disparaging.
Key takeaways
- AI assistants turn "which plumber / dentist / accountant?" into web searches and read the pages that come back. A fair, factual comparison page is built for exactly that search.
- Use a table of named businesses. Every cell is a checkable fact with a source and a date; no adjectives, including about yourself.
- Source each row from the competitor's own website or a public register, keep the evidence, and show a "checked on" date on the page.
- UK law and the CAP Code allow naming competitors if the comparison is objective, verifiable and does not denigrate anyone.
- Refresh the page quarterly and whenever a competitor changes something you listed.
Why do AI assistants quote comparison pages?
Because a comparison page is the closest thing on the web to the answer the customer asked for.
Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode may use "query fan-out", "issuing multiple related searches across subtopics and data sources" to build a response (Google Search Central, 2025). ChatGPT "typically rewrites your query into one or more targeted queries" and "may send additional, more specific queries" after reading the first results (OpenAI Help Center, 2026). Perplexity's fetcher "might visit a web page to help provide an accurate answer" and may "include a link to the page in its response" (Perplexity, 2026).
So "which emergency electrician in Leeds is NICEIC registered and works weekends?" (an illustrative example) becomes several searches about electricians, Leeds, NICEIC and weekend hours. A page naming three or four Leeds electricians with those facts in a table is a direct hit for every one.
Google's content advice points the same way: it asks for "unique expert or experienced takes that go beyond common knowledge and the ordinary", warns that "a summary of existing content simply restates information already available elsewhere", and says its AI features "can show what's being said about products and services across the web" (Google Search Central, 2026). A dated table of local facts nobody else has compiled is unique content by that definition, and the kind of page local sites link to.
No platform publishes a ranking formula, and OpenAI says "placement is not guaranteed" (OpenAI Help Center, 2026). What follows is the structure most likely to be picked up, not a promise.
Which questions should the page answer?
Start from the questions customers actually put to assistants, then write one page per question group.
Two ways to find them:
- Run a free check. The SearchCrow check asks ChatGPT and Perplexity five questions a customer might ask and shows which businesses were named instead of you. Those questions and businesses are your starting list.
- By hand. Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and Google AI Mode a comparison question ("best [service] in [town]"), a constraint ("[service] in [town] that does X") and a price question (illustrative examples). Note which businesses are named and which sites are cited.
Pick a question where you genuinely compete well on facts. If three competitors have better scores, lower prices and longer hours, a comparison page will say so. If the facts don't help you yet, fix them first (see our AI visibility checklist) and come back.
Title the page with the question itself: "Emergency electricians in Leeds compared (checked November 2026)". "Why we're the best" matches nothing anyone types.
What should a comparison page contain?
A short introduction, a table of named businesses with checkable facts, your sources, and a date.
| Part | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| Direct answer (2–3 sentences) | Who the page compares, for which need, in which area, and the date it was checked |
| The table | One row per business, including you; one column per fact (see below) |
| How we compiled this | Where each fact came from, when, and how to ask for a correction |
| What to ask any provider | Three or four questions a customer should ask whoever they choose |
| Last checked | A visible date, updated every time you re-verify |
Columns that work for most local services:
- Services offered, in the words the business uses on its own site
- Areas covered, as listed by the business
- Opening hours, including whether evenings and weekends are listed
- Accreditations and registrations, with the register and registration number where public (for example Gas Safe, NICEIC, SRA, GDC, CQC, FCA, ICAEW)
- Price from, copied exactly as published, with what it covers
- Review score: platform, score, review count and the date you looked
- Years trading or incorporation date, from Companies House where the business is a company
Rules for every cell:
- Facts only. "Open Saturdays 8–1" is a fact. "Friendly, reliable service" is your opinion; leave it out for everyone, including yourself.
- Same columns for every row. If you list your NICEIC number, list theirs. If a competitor doesn't publish a price, write "not published", not a guess.
- Quote, don't interpret. Copy "from £85 + VAT" as written, not "around £100".
- You are a row, not a headline. Put yourself in alphabetical order with the others.
Keep the direct answer and the table at the top; they are the parts an assistant is most likely to lift.
Where do I get the facts, and how do I keep them honest?
Every entry comes from the competitor's own website or a public register, and you keep a dated copy of what you saw.
- Competitor websites. Services, areas, hours and prices come from their own pages. Save a screenshot or PDF of each with the date.
- Public registers. Check accreditations on the issuing body's register, not the competitor's claim: the Gas Safe Register, the SRA's Find a Solicitor, the GDC register, the CQC, the FCA register, and Companies House for incorporation dates. Record the register, the number and the date.
- Review platforms. Google, Trustpilot, Checkatrade or whichever your trade uses. Record platform, score, count and date for every business, from the same platform.
- Nothing else. Not hearsay, not a customer's story, not an old price you remember.
The CAP Code says marketers "must hold documentary evidence" for objective claims before publishing, and "the ASA may regard claims as misleading in the absence of adequate substantiation" (rule 3.7, CAP, 2026). The ASA's advice on verifiability says ads "should clearly explain how readers can verify a comparison", with the information "immediately and prominently on a landing page" (ASA, 2026). A "How we compiled this" section linking each source does exactly that.
Can I name competitors on my website in the UK?
Yes, if the comparison is accurate, objective, verifiable and does not run anyone down. Four sets of rules matter; none stops a fair comparison.
The CAP Code (enforced by the ASA)
The comparison rules are in section 3 of the Code (CAP, 2026):
| Rule | What it says a comparison must do |
|---|---|
| 3.33 | "compare products meeting the same needs or intended for the same purpose" |
| 3.34 | "objectively compare one or more material, relevant, verifiable and representative feature of those products, which may include price" |
| 3.35 | not "create confusion between the marketer and its competitors" or their trade names and marks |
| 3.38 | a price comparison "must not mislead by failing to make the basis of the comparison clear" |
| 3.39 | "must not mislead by falsely claiming a price advantage" |
| 3.41 | "must not discredit or denigrate another product, marketer, trade mark, trade name or other distinguishing mark" |
| 3.42 | "must not take unfair advantage of the reputation of a competitor's trade mark, trade name or other distinguishing mark" |
These rules apply whenever "it is possible for a consumer to name at least one competitor or competing product", so "the other big firm in town" counts as well as a named one (ASA, 2026). Marketers "should hold documentary evidence to back up all comparative claims" (ASA, 2025).
The Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008
Regulation 4 permits comparative advertising "only when" its conditions are met, including that it "compares products meeting the same needs or intended for the same purpose", "objectively compares one or more material, relevant, verifiable and representative features of those products, which may include price", and "does not discredit or denigrate the trade marks, trade names, other distinguishing marks, products, activities, or circumstances of a competitor" (legislation.gov.uk, 2026). The same tests as the CAP rules, with the force of law.
Defamation, in plain terms
A table of true facts is not defamatory; the risk is in commentary. Under the Defamation Act 2013, a statement is not defamatory unless it "has caused or is likely to cause serious harm" to reputation, which for a business means "serious financial loss" (legislation.gov.uk, 2026), and truth is a defence (legislation.gov.uk, 2026). "Not found on the Gas Safe Register on 10 November 2026" is defensible if your dated check shows it; "cowboys" is not. Write nothing about a competitor you could not prove, and keep the proof.
Reviews, and the CMA
The CMA's reviews guidance covers traders who publish "consumer reviews or consumer review information from any source", including information "originally collated by someone else", and defines review information as "aggregated information in the form of overall ratings, review summaries, review counts and rankings" (Competition and Markets Authority, 2025). Publishing "false or misleading consumer review information" is banned; the full guidance is CMA208 (Competition and Markets Authority, 2025). In practice: same platform for every row, score plus count plus date, and no single glowing review of yourself beside a single bad one of theirs.
A worked example for one trade
Here is the shape of a page for emergency electricians in a city. Every business, number and detail below is invented to show the format; do not copy any of it.
Title: Emergency electricians in Leeds compared (checked 10 November 2026)
Direct answer: This page compares four electricians who list emergency call-outs in Leeds, including us (Example Electrical). Each fact was taken from the business's own website or the NICEIC and Companies House registers on 10 November 2026. Ask any of them for a written quote before work starts.
| Business (illustrative) | Emergency call-out hours listed | Areas listed | NICEIC registered (register checked) | Call-out price from (as published) | Google reviews (score, count, 10 Nov 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aire Valley Sparks | Mon–Fri 7am–7pm | Leeds, Bradford | Yes | £75 + VAT, first hour | 4.7, 212 |
| Example Electrical (us) | 24 hours, 7 days | Leeds, Wakefield | Yes | £95 + VAT, first hour | 4.9, 88 |
| Headrow Electrics Ltd | 24 hours, 7 days | Leeds only | Yes | Not published | 4.6, 341 |
| Kirkstall Electrical Services | Mon–Sat 8am–6pm | Leeds, Harrogate | Not found on register | £60, first hour (VAT not stated) | 4.8, 54 |
How we compiled this: Hours, areas and prices are copied from each business's website on 10 November 2026 (links to each page). NICEIC status was checked on the NICEIC register and review figures on each Google Business Profile the same day. If you run one of these businesses and something has changed, email us and we will update the row within a week.
What to ask any electrician: Is the price per hour or per job? Does it include parts? Will I get a certificate for the work?
Notice what the example does not do. It doesn't call anyone cheap, slow or unqualified. "Not found on register" states what the check found, with the date. The owner's own row has the smallest review count, and it still says so.
What should I not do?
These mistakes turn a reference page into an advert, and advertising copy is what assistants have least reason to quote.
- Adjectives. "Trusted", "leading", "best value". Delete them from every row.
- Mixed sources. Your Google score against their Trustpilot score, or your "from" price against their average invoice. Rule 3.38 asks for the basis of a price comparison to be clear.
- Guessed cells. If they don't publish it, write "not published".
- Fake "independent" framing. Say on the page that you run one of the businesses.
- Competitors' names in your page title or URL to borrow their search traffic. Rule 3.42 is aimed at exactly that.
- A page that never changes. OpenAI tells users to check "when it was published or updated" (OpenAI Help Center, 2026). A 2024 date on a comparison is a reason to skip it.
- Blocking the crawlers that would read it. Sites that opt out of OAI-SearchBot "will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers" (OpenAI, 2026), and Google can only use a page that is indexed and "eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet" (Google Search Central, 2025). See our guide to allowing ChatGPT to crawl your website.
How often should I refresh it, and how do I know it's working?
Re-check every row quarterly, update the visible date, and watch whether assistants start naming you for the question.
- Quarterly reminder. Re-open every source, update what changed, move the "checked on" date.
- Same-day updates when you hear of a change: a competitor's new price or lapsed registration makes your page wrong until you fix it.
- Invite corrections on the page and act within a week. It is also your best defence if anyone objects.
- Ask the assistants the question monthly. Note whether you are named, whether your page is cited, and which other sites are; those are where to earn a mention next. Our guide on why AI recommends a competitor explains how to read the citations.
- Add the next question. The second page (a different need, or a neighbouring town) is much quicker.
How SearchCrow helps
When SearchCrow's action plan finds a question where assistants name competitors and not you, it adds a "publish a comparison page" action with a draft: the question, the businesses the assistants named, the columns to fill and the "How we compiled this" wording, ready for you to verify each cell and date it. The dashboard then shows whether assistants start naming you for that question and whether your page appears among the cited sources. The draft follows the structure in this guide, so you can build the page without SearchCrow; it just saves the first hour. Plans start free; see /pricing.
FAQ
Can I name my competitors on my own website in the UK? Yes, if the comparison is fair. The Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008 permit comparative advertising only when it is not misleading, compares products meeting the same needs, objectively compares material, relevant, verifiable and representative features, and does not discredit or denigrate a competitor. The CAP Code, enforced by the ASA, has matching rules at 3.33 to 3.42. Stick to checkable facts and you are on solid ground.
Why would an AI assistant quote a comparison page rather than my home page? Because it answers the question the customer actually asked. When someone asks which business to choose, ChatGPT rewrites the question into targeted searches and Google's AI features run several related searches, then both read the pages that come back. A page that already lists the options side by side, with facts, matches those searches far better than a home page that only talks about you.
Should I include myself in the comparison table? Yes, as one row among the others, described in exactly the same terms. Leave out adjectives and claims you cannot evidence. A table where every row is a checkable fact reads as a reference, which is what AI assistants and sceptical customers both want. A table where your row says 'excellent' and the others say nothing is an advert, and a weak one.
Can I quote competitors' review scores on a comparison page? You can show a score, but treat it carefully. The CMA's guidance on reviews applies to any business that publishes consumer review information, including overall ratings and review counts originally collated by someone else. Show the platform, the score, the number of reviews and the date you looked, for every business including your own, and never pick the one platform that flatters you.
How often should a comparison page be updated? Check every row at least quarterly, and the day you learn a competitor has changed prices, hours or accreditation. Google says its AI features retrieve up-to-date pages from its index, and OpenAI tells ChatGPT users to check when a cited source was published or updated. A page with a visible 'checked on' date that is less than three months old is more useful than a stale one.
What if a competitor complains about the page? If every entry comes from their own website or a public register, dated and with your evidence saved, you can show them where it came from and correct anything that has changed. The ASA expects marketers to hold documentary evidence for comparative claims. Fix genuine errors quickly, keep the tone neutral, and the page remains defensible.
Sources
- Google Search Central, Optimizing for generative AI features on Google Search
- Google Search Central, AI features and your website
- OpenAI Help Center, Searching the web with ChatGPT
- OpenAI, Overview of OpenAI crawlers
- Perplexity, Perplexity crawlers
- Committee of Advertising Practice, CAP Code section 3: Misleading advertising
- ASA / CAP Advice Online, Comparisons: General (10 November 2025)
- ASA / CAP Advice Online, Comparisons: Identifiable competitors (27 August 2026)
- ASA / CAP Advice Online, Comparisons: Verifiability (31 July 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk, The Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008, regulation 4
- legislation.gov.uk, Defamation Act 2013, section 1 and section 2
- Competition and Markets Authority, Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (4 April 2025)
- Competition and Markets Authority, Fake reviews (CMA208) (4 April 2025)