Guide

Generative engine optimization services: should a small business pay for them?

Updated · 11 min read · By the SearchCrow team

Generative engine optimization (GEO) services are packages that aim to get your business named when someone asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot or Google's AI features for a recommendation. The work inside them is mostly ordinary: making your site readable by AI crawlers, writing pages that answer customers' questions, tidying listings and reviews, and tracking whether assistants mention you. Google says optimising for its AI features is "still SEO" with no special requirements, and OpenAI says placement in ChatGPT is not guaranteed, so pay for the work and the reporting, never for a promised position.

Key takeaways

  • A GEO service is a bundle of known tasks, not a secret method. Ask for the task list.
  • No platform has published its ranking factors, so no provider can guarantee a result in any assistant.
  • The same work can be done by an agency, a freelancer, you with a tool, or not at all. Each has a different cost shape and risk.
  • The right choice depends mostly on how much time you have and how much a new customer is worth to you.
  • Walk away from guaranteed ChatGPT rankings, "AI directory submissions", bulk mentions and any form of fake review.

What do GEO services usually include?

Most generative engine optimisation services combine the same four components, whatever they are called on the proposal.

  1. A technical check. Can the AI search crawlers read your site? Is anything in robots.txt, your host's bot protection or your page templates stopping them? Are your key facts in plain text rather than images or scripts? Our AI visibility checklist covers the same ground step by step.
  2. Content. Service pages rewritten to answer questions directly, FAQ pages, comparison pages and sometimes articles, written so an assistant can lift a clear answer with your name attached. See how to write a comparison page that AI quotes.
  3. Listings, mentions and reviews. Checking your Google Business Profile and other listings are complete and consistent, getting you onto directories and publications that assistants cite, and running a review request process.
  4. Tracking and reporting. Asking the assistants a fixed set of questions on a schedule, recording whether you are named, who is named instead and which sites are cited, then reporting it monthly.

Some providers add structured data (schema markup), an llms.txt file or "AI-ready" page rewrites. Google says structured data "isn't required for generative AI search" and that "you don't need to create new machine readable files, AI text files, markup, or Markdown to appear in Google Search" (Google Search Central, 2026). Schema can still help search engines read your details accurately, but treat it as a small item on the list, not the reason to sign.

We describe these components generically rather than quoting any one agency's service page. The point is that every item above is a task you can see, check and, if you choose, do yourself.

What does Google say about generative engine optimisation?

Google's position is that GEO and AEO are new names for SEO, and that its AI features need nothing extra.

Its documentation acknowledges that "terms like Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) or Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) are common online", then states that "optimizing for generative AI search is optimizing for the search experience, and thus still SEO" (Google Search Central, 2026). Its page on AI features is blunter: "There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary", and "the best practices for SEO remain relevant for AI features in Google Search" (Google Search Central, 2025).

Two consequences for someone being pitched GEO services:

  • If a provider's AI work is separate from their SEO work and priced separately, ask what is actually different. A good local SEO provider should already be doing most of it. Our guide to GEO, AEO and SEO for small businesses sets out the overlap.
  • Google only speaks for Google. OpenAI, Perplexity, Anthropic and Microsoft each run their own search and crawlers, and the ways to be eligible differ slightly. Our guide to how AI assistants choose businesses lists what each has published.

What can a GEO provider promise, and what can't they?

A provider can promise work, reporting and honest measurement. Nobody can promise a position in an AI answer.

OpenAI's help centre says "ChatGPT ranks search results using multiple factors intended to help users find relevant, reliable information. Placement is not guaranteed." OpenAI's crawler documentation adds that "it can take ~24 hours from a site's robots.txt update for our systems to adjust" (OpenAI, 2026). The only eligibility step the help centre documents is to "allow OAI-Searchbot to crawl the site and confirm that the website host or content delivery network allows traffic from OpenAI's published searchbot IP addresses" (OpenAI Help Center, 2026).

Google says that for its AI features "indexing and serving isn't guaranteed", that "the set of responses and links they show will vary", and that AI Overviews "are only shown when our systems determine that it is additive to classic Search" (Google Search Central, 2025).

So a reasonable provider can commit to:

  • making your site eligible on every assistant (crawlers allowed, pages indexed, facts in plain text);
  • publishing an agreed number of pages or listings each month;
  • running the same set of customer questions on a schedule and reporting the share that name you, with the raw answers available;
  • explaining what changed and what they will try next.

They cannot honestly commit to a rank, a number of mentions, or a date by which you will appear. If the contract contains one, the fee is buying a promise the platforms themselves refuse to make.

What should I ask a GEO agency before signing?

Ask these seven questions and insist on written answers. Vague replies to any of them are a reason to keep looking.

  1. Which assistants do you cover? ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, Gemini, Claude and Copilot behave differently. A provider who says "AI" without naming them probably isn't checking them.
  2. How do you measure? You want a fixed list of the questions your customers ask (illustrative examples: "best emergency plumber in Leeds", "which accountant should a freelance designer use"), asked repeatedly, with the share of answers naming you. One screenshot is not a measurement, because answers vary between runs.
  3. What is in the monthly report? At minimum: the questions, your mention share, who was named instead, which sites were cited, and what was done. For Google's AI features, ask whether they use the Search Console Generative AI performance report, which Google introduced in June 2026 and which shows "how often URLs from your site appeared in generative AI features in Search and Discover" (Google Search Central Blog, 2026).
  4. What do you do each month? Get the task list: pages written, listings claimed, reviews requested, technical fixes. If month three looks the same as month one with nothing shipped, you are paying for monitoring you could run yourself.
  5. Who owns the content and the accounts? Pages, Business Profile access, directory logins and any tracking data should be yours and should stay yours if you leave.
  6. How long before results? The honest answer is "we don't know exactly, and here is how we'll know whether it is working". A confident fixed date is a warning sign.
  7. What happens if nothing changes after three months? Look for a provider who will change the plan rather than ask for patience indefinitely.

Agency, freelancer, do it yourself with a tool, or do nothing?

The same work can be bought four ways. The table compares them honestly; the right row depends on your time and the value of a customer.

OptionYour timeCost shapeWhat you getMain risks
AgencyLow: a monthly call and approvalsMonthly retainer, usually with a minimum termA team doing technical, content, listings and reporting; account managementPaying for packaging; vague reporting; content that doesn't sound like you; lock-in
FreelancerLow to medium: more briefing and checkingDay rate or project fee, sometimes a small retainerA specialist doing the parts you choose; usually cheaper than an agency for the same tasksSingle person's availability; may cover only one component; you still need to measure
Do it yourself with a toolMedium: a few hours a monthSoftware subscription, no minimum termMeasurement done for you, a prioritised list of fixes and drafts; you do the publishing and listingsNeeds your attention each month; you write or edit the content; some fixes need a web developer
Do nothingNoneNothing nowWhatever assistants already say about you, right or wrongCompetitors get named instead; wrong facts go uncorrected; you can't see either happening

A few notes on the cost column. We have not published pounds-per-month ranges for agencies or freelancers because we couldn't verify any; ask for quotes against the same written scope so you can compare them. For the tool option, SearchCrow's own plans are a verified reference point: a free plan, then Starter at £29 a month, Growth at £79 and Agency at £199 (SearchCrow, 2026). Other tools' prices are on their own pricing pages; our comparison of AI visibility tools for small businesses covers them.

Which option makes sense for my size of business?

Match the option to the value of a customer and the time you can give it, not to the size of the pitch.

  • Sole trader or very small local business (a plumber, barber, therapist, cafe): start with doing it yourself with a tool, or with nothing more than a free check. Most of the fixes are listings, reviews and plain-text facts on a handful of pages, and you know your trade better than any writer. Move to a freelancer when you have a specific job you can't do, such as rebuilding a slow site.
  • Small business with a marketing budget but no marketer (a dental practice, letting agent, accountancy firm, independent shop): a freelancer or a modest tool subscription plus an existing SEO or web provider usually covers it. Ask your current provider the seven questions above before paying someone new; they may already be doing most of the work.
  • Growing business with high-value customers (solicitors, consultants, B2B services, SaaS): an agency retainer can be worth it if each new client is worth thousands, provided the reporting is specific and you own everything produced. Use a tool alongside them so you have your own measurement rather than relying on their report.
  • Agencies and freelancers themselves: if you are on the other side of this conversation, our guide on how to offer AI visibility as a service covers scoping and reporting it properly.

Whichever route you choose, run a free check first so you know where you stand before anyone tells you.

What are the red flags in GEO services?

Some offers are not just overpriced but harmful. Decline these outright.

  • Guaranteed rankings in ChatGPT, Perplexity or any assistant. OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed and Google says serving isn't guaranteed and responses vary (OpenAI Help Center, 2026; Google Search Central, 2025). Nobody outside those companies can override that.
  • "AI directory submissions". Paid listings on sites that exist only to sell listings. The test is simple: ask which assistants have cited that directory, for which questions, and ask to see the answer. If the provider can't show it, the directory is not where assistants look. Our guide to directories AI assistants cite in the UK lists ones that are.
  • Bulk mentions or "AI-generated citations". Hundreds of low-quality articles or forum posts naming you. Google's advice is to create content people find "unique, compelling, and useful" (Google Search Central, 2026); mass-produced mentions are the opposite, and they are the kind of thing search engines work to discount.
  • Fake, bought or incentivised reviews. Google's Business Profile policy says "fake engagement is not allowed and will be removed" and prohibits "content that has been posted due to an incentive offered by a business" (Google Business Profile Help, 2026). In the UK, the Competition and Markets Authority published guidance for businesses that publish reviews, to help them comply with legislative changes introduced in April 2025 (CMA, 2025). A provider offering reviews as a deliverable is offering you a policy breach.
  • Secret ranking factors. Anyone who says they know how ChatGPT or Gemini chooses businesses knows more than the companies have published. Treat it as sales talk.
  • No raw data. If you can't see the actual questions asked and the actual answers returned, you can't tell whether the report is real.

How SearchCrow helps

SearchCrow is the do-it-yourself-with-a-tool row of the table above. The free check reads your website, asks ChatGPT and Perplexity five questions a customer might ask, checks your site the way AI crawlers see it, and shows a score, which assistants named you, who was named instead and the top three fixes, in about 30 seconds with no card. Paid plans track 25 to 150 questions across up to seven assistants (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Copilot, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode), check them weekly, compare you with competitors, show the sites assistants cite, and turn the gaps into an action plan with step-by-step fixes and drafts you can edit and publish. Everything an agency would report to you is on the dashboard, and the work itself is yours to do or to hand to a freelancer with a clear brief. Plan details are on the pricing page.

FAQ

What do generative engine optimization services actually include? Most packages combine four things: a technical check that AI search crawlers can read your site, answer-first content written for the questions customers ask, listings and reviews work so other sites mention you, and monthly tracking of whether assistants such as ChatGPT and Perplexity name you. Each of these is a known task. None of it is secret, which is why you should ask a provider to list exactly what they do each month.

Is GEO different from SEO? Google says no. Its documentation states that optimising for generative AI search is optimising for the search experience, and thus still SEO, and that there are no additional requirements or special optimisations needed for AI Overviews or AI Mode. The work overlaps almost entirely with good local SEO. What differs is how you write (answer first) and how you measure (mentions in answers, not positions in a list).

Can a GEO agency guarantee my business will appear in ChatGPT? No. OpenAI's help centre says ChatGPT ranks search results using multiple factors and that placement is not guaranteed. Google says indexing and serving aren't guaranteed and that the responses and links its AI features show will vary. A provider can promise the work and the reporting, and can reasonably expect improvement, but anyone guaranteeing a position in an AI answer is promising something the platforms themselves won't.

How much do GEO services cost? There is no standard rate card, and we don't publish price ranges we can't verify. Costs fall into three shapes: a monthly retainer with an agency, day or project rates with a freelancer, or a software subscription if you do it yourself. As a reference point, SearchCrow's own plans run from a free tier to £29, £79 and £199 a month. Ask any provider for a written scope so you can compare like with like.

How long before GEO work shows results? Nobody can give an honest fixed timescale, because no platform publishes its ranking factors. Some fixes act quickly: OpenAI says robots.txt changes take about 24 hours to apply. Content, listings and reviews take longer, and Google notes that AI Overviews only appear when its systems judge them useful. Measure over repeated checks rather than a single screenshot, and expect to review progress monthly.

What are the red flags when choosing a GEO provider? Guaranteed rankings in ChatGPT or any assistant; paid 'AI directory submissions' with no evidence that assistants cite those directories; bulk mentions or AI-written reviews; and vague reporting with no record of which questions were asked. Fake or incentivised reviews break Google's Business Profile rules and UK consumer law guidance, so a provider offering them puts your listing and your business at risk.

Sources

Free check

Does ChatGPT recommend your business?

Free, in under a minute. You’ll see whether AI assistants mention you, who they recommend instead, and your top 3 fixes.

We’ll read your website for your business details, so there’s less to type.

Free, no card needed. We ask ChatGPT and Perplexity 5 questions your customers might ask, and check your website. We use your email to send you your results and a few short follow-ups about them, which you can stop with one click; see our privacy notice.